Are Mormons Christians?

Are Mormons Christian?  This is a debate that will never end, because each side has its own definition as to what constitutes a Christian.  Ask a Mormon who he or she worships and the Mormon will say “Christ.”  A follower of Christ is a Christian. The critic will rebut Mormons believe in “a different Christ.”  Because critics of the Mormon Church misrepresent the Church’s teachings and use catch-phrases to discredit the Church, the Mormon will often state his belief, and the critic will tell him that Mormons really believe something else.  What is really at issue is the definition of “Christian.”  For Christians outside the Mormon Church, the definition relies on several points of doctrine.  The many denominations of Christianity have their differences, but agree on basic traditional principles.  Those first called Christian at Antioch certainly believed differently than any contemporary Christian or Mormon, but without knowledge of their beliefs they remain safe from criticism, but the doctrine of Mormonism is well-known and well-criticized.

A Different Jesus

The claim that Mormons are not Christian is mostly founded on particular definitions created according to the accuser’s beliefs.  One of the arguments denying that Mormons are Christian claims that Mormons believe in a “different” Jesus.  The “proper” Jesus is defined almost wholly from the writings in the Bible.  The New Testament gives accounts of the ministry of Jesus and contains writings of the Apostles.  What the Christian world knows about Jesus, it knows from the New Testament, and Mormons also accept it as the word of God.  The exclusion comes from the belief about the nature of Jesus Christ by interpretation of the Bible.

Most of those asking “Are Mormons Christian?” believe in the Nicene doctrine of the Trinity.  This council defined God according to Greek influences that the immaterial is more perfect than the corporeal, and thus God must be immaterial.  This immaterial God could be everywhere and nowhere, and anything divine would be part of God.  For Jesus to be divine, He became the incarnation of God, and the Holy Spirit became the influence.  Mormons do not believe this is the nature of God.  Mormons believe that the Trinity is three separate beings that together are God.  The Father possesses a body, not a mortal body of flesh and blood like man, but a perfect, immortal, glorious body.  Jesus is the literal Son of God, they are not of one substance but are Father and Son.  Now resurrected, Jesus too possesses a perfect, immortal body like His Father.  The Holy Ghost is a spirit, and is thus able to influence everywhere at once.  One question shows how unfathomable the old Trinitarian notions really are.  Why was Jesus resurrected?  He was resurrected so that we can be resurrected.  Most Christian faiths believe in a universal resurrection.  But to believe in a trinity as a spirit-entity, means that Christ discarded His perfect, resurrected body in order to return to the God-entity.  If we sit very still for a moment and meditate, the natural belief that settles and makes us peaceful, is that Christ was resurrected because it is the eternally desirable and perfected state, and that He continues as a perfect, resurrected being.

In 3 Nephi 28:10, it says, “And for this cause ye shall have fulness of joy; and ye shall sit down in the kingdom of my Father; yea, your joy shall be full, even as the Father hath given me fulness of joy; and ye shall be even as I am, and I am even as the Father; and the Father and I are one.”

In Doctrine and Covenants section 138, it says, “Their sleeping dust was to be restored unto its perfect frame, bone to his bone, and the sinews and the flesh upon them, the spirit and the body to be united never again to be divided, that they might receive a fulness of joy.”

A Bible! A Bible!

Another aspect of the question “Are Mormons Christian?” deals with scripture.  Mormons believe the Bible because it contains the words of prophets.  After Christ and the Apostles were killed, it is generally thought among Christianity that revelation ceased.  For a long time there was no one on the earth with the prophetic authority that had been given to the Apostles by Jesus.  As a result, Christianity was left to interpretation by scholars, and sectarian divisions were the result.

Prophetic and Apostolic authority was restored to Joseph Smith.  Under this same authority through which other prophets had written, Joseph Smith brought forth additional scriptures, the Book of Mormon, the Doctrine and Covenants, and the Pearl of Great Price.  Those that ask ‘Are Mormons Christian?’ believe the Bible is complete and cannot be added to.  First, the Bible is a compilation and was not written as a single book by its authors; when Deuteronomy 4:2 and Revelation 22:18-19 were written, which say the Bible cannot be added to, the Bible did not exist as it does now, so it was added to; the meaning of the passages is to not add to the gospel.  All Mormon scripture supports the belief in Jesus Christ and is in line with the gospel as found in the New Testament.  Second, the words of all the prophets who ever lived are not all contained in the Bible.  Jesus’ warning of false prophets does not mean that there will never be true prophets.  Mormons believe when a prophet speaks on behalf of God that it is truth, and there are modern prophets that are doing it.  Many Christians believe there are no more prophets, but this does not make it a qualification for Christian belief.

Here, another question creates a stalemate.  What about the Ten Lost Tribes?  Bible prophecy holds that they will return, and that their return will be accompanied by miracles so great that the whole world will take notice.  These tribes split off from those captured by the Assyrians and carried off.  They had repented, and through the grace of God, were led into sanctuary, where they have remained hidden from the world.  They have had prophets and written scripture, which the Mormon Church will receive with gratitude.  Should the entire Christian world then reject it, because the Bible allows for no more revelatory scripture?  Why should we limit the Lord in that way?

Thou fool, that shall say: A Bible, we have got a Bible, and we need no more Bible. Have ye obtained a Bible save it were by the Jews? Know ye not that there are more nations than one? Know ye not that I, the Lord your God, have created all men, and that I remember those who are upon the isles of the sea; and that I rule in the heavens above and in the earth beneath; and I bring forth my word unto the children of men, yea, even upon all the nations of the earth?

What Do You Mean By ‘Christian’?

The debate asking “Are Mormons Christian?” centers on the belief in continuing revelation.  Mormons believe revelation through designated prophets to the western world ceased with the death of the Apostles and then was restored through Joseph Smith.  The rest of Christianity believes that revelation ceased for good.  Without revelation the doctrines by which much of Christianity defines itself today (and attempts to define others) were established.  Mormons believe the truths of the gospel were restored by Joseph Smith, such as the nature of the Godhead, the organization of His Church, the authority to act in God’s name, and the ordinances necessary for salvation.  And by a commandment of God the Book of Mormon and other scriptures were brought forth for the benefit of the believers.  So the answer to the question “Are Mormons Christian?” depends on the meaning of “Christian.”  If it means the concept of an immaterial God who has closed the heavens, then no, Mormons do not believe that.  But if “Christians” are those who follow Christ, who try to live according to His commandments, who exercise charity in His name, among whom are found the spiritual gifts that accompany faith in Him, then the answer is “yes.”  Despite differences of opinion and interpretation, Mormons follow Christ.